Joe Carr watched a bulldozer crush fellow
activist Rachel Corrie in Gaza two years ago. Weeks later,
he witnessed the shooting of another activist, Tom Hurndall,
in the same region.
The violence only fueled the 23-year-old
Kansas City resident's desire to help people in the
turbulent Middle East.
“It was just incredibly affecting to me
and really connected me to the Palestinian struggle,” he
said.
Carr and Andrea Whitmore, also of Kansas
City, recently returned from separate trips to the Middle
East. Both are members of the local Citizens for Justice in
the Middle East, which tries to educate the public about the
conflict and to end U.S. support for the Israeli occupation
of the Palestinian territories.
The two activists traveled with different
groups but share a hope for peace in the region, a
frustration with U.S. policy and a desire to share their
stories with others. Both will be giving public talks about
their experiences.
“It's a moral responsibility to speak
out,” said Whitmore, a writer and former teacher at the
University of Missouri-Kansas City.
Others in the Kansas City area, of course,
hold different political views.
Marvin Szneler, executive director of the
Jewish Community Relations Bureau/American Jewish Committee,
said few people believe that U.S. policy prevents peace.
“I think that's a very fringe view,” he
said, adding that it has been refuted even by the
Palestinian Authority.
Szneler, who recently visited the region,
said former Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat's death has
many feeling optimistic.
“Israel is the most hopeful it's been in
years,” he said.
Carr returned in December from a
three-month trip to the Middle East where he worked as a
member of Christian Peacemaker Teams. He spent much of his
time in the West Bank city of Hebron.
It was his second trip to the region. Carr
traveled there in 2003 as a member of the International
Solidarity Movement, an organization that included Corrie
and Hurndall.
Huwaida Arraf, a co-founder of the
organization, confirmed that Carr witnessed both incidents
involving Corrie and Hurndall.
Their deaths made international headlines.
Corrie, a student at Evergreen State College in Olympia,
Wash., was killed in March 2003 while protesting home
demolitions by the Israelis. A month later, Hurndall, a
British activist, was shot in the head while attempting to
protect Palestinian children. He died months later.
Carr's latest trip was calmer, he said,
though he was jailed at one point.
Carr helped Palestinians build a clinic.
He guided young Palestinian children who had to walk near
Israeli settlements to get to school. And he walked the
fields with Palestinian farmers and shepherds whose land
bordered Israeli settlements.
The children were harassed and abused on
their way to school, he said. Efforts to bring attention to
the children's plight ultimately led to the children
receiving police or military escort, he said.
“Sometimes, even with the police presence,
(settlers have) attacked them and harassed them,” Carr said.
“What I do consider a success is that people are paying
attention a little bit.”
Carr said he was arrested while monitoring
checkpoints with another activist.
“It was so absurd,” he said of the
incident. “They interrogated us. They tried to intimidate
me. They got in my face.”
After about six hours in jail, he said, he
was released.
Carr's work has garnered praise from
fellow activists at home.
“From my perspective, Joe has taken a very
courageous step to try to make a difference in this part of
the world,” said Matt Quinn, president of the local Citizens
for Justice in the Middle East.
Carr, a graduate of Center High School and
Evergreen State College, has always looked out for other
people, said his mother, Jackie Carr.
“He always wanted to save the world, even
when he was a little boy,” she said.
But Jackie Carr worries about her son's
safety. She thinks of Corrie and sees how close her own son
is to the violence.
“It could have been him,” she said.
Some of Carr's journals are on the
Internet, and his mother fears he could make enemies with
people he doesn't know.
But Carr said he's willing to stand up for
his beliefs.
He has made a three-year commitment with
Christian Peacemaker Teams and believes he will return to
the Middle East. Even while his mother worries.
“If something happens to him, he was doing
what he believes was important,” Jackie Carr said.
Whitmore, who lives near Penn Valley
Community College in midtown Kansas City, spent two weeks in
October in the Middle East with Interfaith Peace Builders, a
team sponsored by the Fellowship of Reconciliation.
Her group, of about eight people of
various ages and backgrounds, met with people on both sides
of the conflict, including Israeli settlers and
Palestinians.
Kendra Froshman, a 23-year-old Californian
who also made the trip, said the activists were united in
their desire to learn firsthand about the situation.
“In the media we see lots of killing and
bullets and people crying,” Froshman said. “Actually
speaking with people there – it's really powerful…People
want to know more deeply what the conflict is all about.”
Whitmore met with people who lost family
members in suicide bombings. And she witnessed the
humiliation imposed on Palestinians, she said.
She saw how many people on both sides want
a peaceful resolution.
“The people are remarkably resilient,”
said the English-born Whitmore. “They go about their
business.”
But many suffer.
“It breaks your heart, because it's not
right that this should go on,” she said.
Carr wants the United States to cut aid to
Israel until that country ends its occupation of the West
Bank and Gaza. He said Israel must stop violating
Palestinian human rights with home demolitions, land
confiscation, curfews and roadblocks, house raids, missile
attacks and brutal repression of nonviolent demonstrations.
“Only then can the U.S. claim to be an
independent arbiter in a lasting peace agreement,” Carr
said.